This bill changes how courts review decisions made by state agencies by eliminating the legal deference (special respect) courts normally give to agency interpretations of laws and rules. Instead, courts must independently interpret what the law means from scratch, and if any doubt remains, must choose the interpretation that best protects individual constitutional rights. The bill also clarifies that appeals of administrative cases to the Supreme Court follow the same standards as other civil appeals, except for this new requirement to review agency interpretations without deference.
Courts must independently review state agency interpretations
Compared on the language each bill adds or strikes, the sections of state law it changes, and its title.
Other states' bills with text similar to this bill's.
A bill for an act relating to interpretation of law in administrative and judicial proceedings under the Iowa administrative procedure Act.
Matching passages cover 54% of this bill's new language and 9% of IA HF 36. Compared as introduced.
IA HF 36 as introduced (legis.iowa.gov) (opens in a new tab)IA HF 36 on openstates.org (opens in a new tab)
Judiciary Deferred to the 41st legislative day Passed, YEAS 4, NAYS 3.
Judiciary Scheduled for hearing
Senate Referred to Senate Judiciary S.J. 142
First Reading Senate S.J. 127
Prime sponsor · Rep
R
Dist. HD-006
Sue Lucas-Peterson
Prime sponsor · Sen
R
Dist. SD-013
Judiciary — Deferred to the 41st legislative day